We've all been reading about lawyers getting sanctioned or otherwise thrown into hot water over fake case citations. This was not a problem prior to artificial intelligence. While AI can do legal research for you, it sometimes invents fake cases or uses real cases for false propositions that do not appear in the case. That may have happened here, and the Court of Appeals is taking action against the lawyer.
The case is Ricketts v. Westwood Condominium Association, a summary order issued on November 18. The plaintiff is representing himself pro se. He brings this case under Title VII, the Fair Housing Act and the Federal Debt Collection Practices Act. The case got dismissed under Rule 12 for failure to state a claim.
Plaintiff did not timely file a notice of appeal from the district court judgment, and that issue takes up the bulk of the Second Circuit's ruling, which finds the notice of appeal was filed too late and the court thus lacks appellate jurisdiction. In this world, the federal notice of appeal is the one deadline that cannot be violated unless you have a damned good reason for it.
What makes the case notable is the fake case citations. I have not seen this in a Second Circuit ruling prior to now, but this was bound to happen sooner or later. The pro se plaintiff cited cases that would have allowed him to proceed with the appeal. But the Second Circuit finds these citations were bogus. The Court (Walker, Jacobs and Bianco) writes:
Additionally, our review of Ricketts’s opening brief revealed evidence that Ricketts cited to a non-existent case. In particular, Ricketts cites “Serebin v. Healthsource Corp.,” represented to be a 1998 decision of the Seventh Circuit. Appellant’s Br. at 6, 34. However, we could not locate a decision by that name, and the citation for that case led us to a different, unpublished case from the Sixth Circuit irrelevant to the issue for which “Serebin” was cited.
Elsewhere, Ricketts cited cases for propositions that they do not support. See, e.g., id. at 22 (citing Int’l Bhd. of Teamsters v. United States, 986 F.2d 15, 20 (2d Cir. 1993) for the proposition that “an attorney’s representation regarding authority to accept service is binding absent extraordinary circumstances,” even though no such proposition is contained in that case); id. at 33 (citing Horgan v. Simmons, 704 F. Supp. 2d 814, 818 (N.D. Ill. 2010), and McBride v. BIC Consumer Prods. Mfg. Co., 583 F.3d 92, 96 (2d Cir. 2009), for the proposition that “[a]sthma has long been recognized as a disability under the ADA where it substantially limits the major life activity of breathing," although neither case involved asthma.
Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires that lawyers certify that their briefs are relying on valid legal authority. The Court of Appeals refers the plaintiff to the Second Circuit's Grievance Penal for further investigation.