The Court of Appeals has sustained the dismissal of a lawsuit brought by five former NYPD officers who challenged New York City's COVID-19 vaccination mandate under the Equal Protection Clause.
The case is McCartney v. City of New York, a summary order issued on November 16. Plaintiffs served in the NYPD's elite Bomb Squad and Emergency Service Unit. After refusing to receive COVID-19 vaccinations required by an October 2021 executive order, they were fired or forced to retire. This scenario was common around the country and in New York. People did not want the vaccine, and their terminations led to multiple lawsuits alleging religious freedom and other rights violations. In this case, plaintiffs argued that the City selectively enforced its vaccination requirements because it imposed the mandate on municipal employees while failing to enforce a separate mandate against private-sector employees and exempting professional athletes and entertainers.
Plaintiffs fail to state a claim under LeClair v. Saunders, 627 F.2d 606 (2d Cir. 1980). LeClair is an important case that does not cited all that often. A selective-enforcement claim -- truly among the more esoteric claims that you can bring under the Constution -- requires plaintiffs to establish that they were treated differently from similarly situated individuals and that the differential treatment resulted from an impermissible discriminatory motivation, an intent to punish the exercise of constitutional rights, or malicious or bad-faith intent to injure.
The Court of Appeals (Menashi, Schwartz and Kahn) holds that plaintiffs lose because they did not allege that the City selectively enforced the vaccination requirement against them compared with other City employees. Instead, they challenged the City's decision to impose a mandate on municipal employees but not the general public. That amounted to a facial challenge to an allegedly underinclusive regulation, not a selective-enforcement claim. The Court cautioned that expanding LeClair to cover such challenges would improperly blur the distinction between facial and as-applied constitutional claims.
Even assuming City employees were similarly situated to the general public concerning the risk of transmitting COVID-19, the different treatment was justified by legitimate governmental interests. Here is where equal protection jurisprudence gets tricky. Some people are more equal than others, and there are special considerations guiding the treatment of some public workers but not others. Here, City employees provide essential services, and the City has a heightened interest in protecting their health and ensuring the continued operation of municipal services. The Court emphasized that government employers enjoy greater latitude in regulating their employees than the government exercises over the public generally.
No comments:
Post a Comment