Ellis Wood was charged with hiring someone to kill the guy who owned a travel agency. When the police took Wood into custody, they began asking him questions, before he said, "I think I should get a lawyer." The police a few minutes later resumed questioning Wood on video, when he made some incriminating statements that he probably would not have made had an attorney been present to tell Wood to shut his mouth. The jury convicted Wood, and the state appellate courts affirmed. Hence the habeas corpus petition in federal court.
The case is Wood v. Ercole, decided on May 4. This case presents a battle of the titans. Judge Lynch wrote the majority opinion. Judge Livingston wrote the dissent. Both were former Assistant U.S. Attorneys who taught at Columbia Law School. Lynch wins out because district judge Sessions signs onto his opinion. Wood gets a new trial because the police should have stopped questioning Wood after he said he wanted a lawyer, prompting Judge Lynch to write a lengthy footnote about the linguistic meaning of the word "think" and whether it is too ambiguous to place the police on notice that they they had to honor the Sixth Amendment.
While the police violated the Sixth Amendment in ignoring Wood's request for counsel, the question is whether this was harmless error. It was not. The admissions that Wood made on video most likely got him convicted, the Court of Appeals says, because the two corroborating witnesses at trial were shaky and had serious credibility problems. One witness, the triggerman, was "the archetypal miscreant" with a long criminal record who lied to the investigators in this very case and committed perjury in a prior case. He also escaped life in prison for his testimony against Wood. His testimony about his agreement with Wood to kill the victim was therefore shaky. The other corroborator was Wood's ex-girlfriend, who claimed that Wood told her he played a role in the killing. She also had credibility problems; she testified to avoid prosecution for her role in a criminal dispute that allegedly motivated Wood to kill the travel agency owner in the first instance. She also faced deportation as a nonlegal resident and she lacked direct knowledge of the murder and did not even think Wood had a role in the killing.
So, it was Wood's confession that got him convicted, not the corroborators who were easy targets on cross-examination. While the Court of Appeals does not even think Wood's confession is that convincing to start with, it did bolster the prosecution's case, and the prosecutor highlighted the video confession in summation. On this record, the Sixth Amendment violation was not harmless at all, and the habeas petition is granted.
Thursday, May 19, 2011
Monday, May 16, 2011
For ADA regulatory mavens only
Under the Americans With Disabilities Act, municipalities have to provide special transportation services to the disabled, particularly for those who need to be picked up and dropped off at home. In Nassau County, this is done through "Able-Ride," which provided door-to-door transportation services. When the County in 2010 modified this service to deal with the budgetary crisis, it got sued for not consulting the public on these cutbacks.
The case is Abrahams v. MTA Long Island Bus, decided on May 5. ADA regulations say that the Department of Transportation has to allow for public participation in the ongoing "development and assessment" of paratransit services. Suing under 42 U.S.C. sec. 1983, plaintiffs argue that defendants violated this mandate. They cannot do so.
Section 1983 allows you to sue if the government has violated a federal civil right. There are limits to this. Under Alexander v. Sandoval, 532 U.S. 275 (2001), the Court said that Congress must intend that federal statutes allow for a private legal claim. In addition, plaintiffs may sue to enforce regulations created to enforce the statute, but to do so, the regulation must merely apply and not expand the statute. This is a subtle but important (and very complicated) distinction that dooms this case.
While the portion of the ADA that gave rise to the regulation may be enforced in a private right of action, the regulation at issue here cannot. The regulation that requires ongoing public participation in the management of paratransit services does not merely enforce that portion of the ADA but, instead, imposes obligations not found in the statute. The Court notes, "the statute requires public participation in connection with the development and submission of a public entity’s initial paratransit plan and annual plan updates. But that is all § 12143 requires in terms of public participation; it does not require any other ongoing form of public participation." Moreover, "the 'ongoing requirement' of 49 C.F.R. § 37.137(c) has a broader application than the implementation of an initial plan or the submission of annual updates." The regulation expands upon the ADA and does not merely enforce it. This means the regulation cannot be enforced under Section 1983.
The case is Abrahams v. MTA Long Island Bus, decided on May 5. ADA regulations say that the Department of Transportation has to allow for public participation in the ongoing "development and assessment" of paratransit services. Suing under 42 U.S.C. sec. 1983, plaintiffs argue that defendants violated this mandate. They cannot do so.
Section 1983 allows you to sue if the government has violated a federal civil right. There are limits to this. Under Alexander v. Sandoval, 532 U.S. 275 (2001), the Court said that Congress must intend that federal statutes allow for a private legal claim. In addition, plaintiffs may sue to enforce regulations created to enforce the statute, but to do so, the regulation must merely apply and not expand the statute. This is a subtle but important (and very complicated) distinction that dooms this case.
While the portion of the ADA that gave rise to the regulation may be enforced in a private right of action, the regulation at issue here cannot. The regulation that requires ongoing public participation in the management of paratransit services does not merely enforce that portion of the ADA but, instead, imposes obligations not found in the statute. The Court notes, "the statute requires public participation in connection with the development and submission of a public entity’s initial paratransit plan and annual plan updates. But that is all § 12143 requires in terms of public participation; it does not require any other ongoing form of public participation." Moreover, "the 'ongoing requirement' of 49 C.F.R. § 37.137(c) has a broader application than the implementation of an initial plan or the submission of annual updates." The regulation expands upon the ADA and does not merely enforce it. This means the regulation cannot be enforced under Section 1983.
Wednesday, May 11, 2011
Win some, lose some under FLSA
The Second Circuit splits the baby in a FLSA case where the plaintiff worked for Black and Decker and was denied certain overtime pay in connection with his work at Home Depot.
The case is Kuebel v. Black & Decker, decided on May 5. Keubel was responsible for setting up Black & Decker displays at Home Depo. He frequently worked overtime because he could not get all the work done in a 40 hour week. Since he worked out in the field, he had to use a Personal Digital Assistant to let management know when he came and went from Home Depot stores. You had to synch the PDA which bounced that information off satellites over to his superiors. He did that at home after work, along with other work-related matters that took up about 30 minutes to an hour each night.
Since Keubel did all this work at home, he wants compensation for his commute. He argues that these tasks were indispensable to his principal job activities, and his workday therefore began and ended at home and encompassed his morning and evening drives to the Home Depot outlets. Good try, but no cigar, the Court of Appeals (Parker, Livingston and Lynch) says. It is true, under Second Circuit precedent, that "periods of time between the commencement of the employee's first principal activity and the completion of his last principle activity on any workday must be included in the computation of hours" to which he is entitled to compensation. But ordinary commutes are not compensable under the FLSA, and "the fact that Kuebel performs some administrative tasks at home, on his own schedule, does not make his commute time compensable any more than it makes his sleep time or his dinner time compensable." Since plaintiff had flexibility in deciding when to complete his daily administrative responsibilities of checking email and voicemail and synching his PDA, among other tasks, he could have done this right before leaving work, as opposed to at night, when he got home. As company policy did not require him to do this immediately after returning home, he does not get any compensation for the commute.
On the other hand, Kuebel's complaint is reinstated on his claim that he was denied overtime for hours that he did not record on his time sheets. The district court rejected plaintiff's claim because he falsified his records to reflect that he did not work overtime and therefore could not prove his damages with precision. The problem with this reasoning is that, according to Keubel, his superiors told him to omit the overtime hours from his time sheets because the company did not want to pay overtime. They told him "you're only supposed to mark forty on your timecard because we can't afford overtime." Acknowledging the realities of life, in addition to the fact that companies cannot delegate their obligation under the FLSA to maintain accurate records of their employees' hours, the Second Circuit says:
The case is Kuebel v. Black & Decker, decided on May 5. Keubel was responsible for setting up Black & Decker displays at Home Depo. He frequently worked overtime because he could not get all the work done in a 40 hour week. Since he worked out in the field, he had to use a Personal Digital Assistant to let management know when he came and went from Home Depot stores. You had to synch the PDA which bounced that information off satellites over to his superiors. He did that at home after work, along with other work-related matters that took up about 30 minutes to an hour each night.
Since Keubel did all this work at home, he wants compensation for his commute. He argues that these tasks were indispensable to his principal job activities, and his workday therefore began and ended at home and encompassed his morning and evening drives to the Home Depot outlets. Good try, but no cigar, the Court of Appeals (Parker, Livingston and Lynch) says. It is true, under Second Circuit precedent, that "periods of time between the commencement of the employee's first principal activity and the completion of his last principle activity on any workday must be included in the computation of hours" to which he is entitled to compensation. But ordinary commutes are not compensable under the FLSA, and "the fact that Kuebel performs some administrative tasks at home, on his own schedule, does not make his commute time compensable any more than it makes his sleep time or his dinner time compensable." Since plaintiff had flexibility in deciding when to complete his daily administrative responsibilities of checking email and voicemail and synching his PDA, among other tasks, he could have done this right before leaving work, as opposed to at night, when he got home. As company policy did not require him to do this immediately after returning home, he does not get any compensation for the commute.
On the other hand, Kuebel's complaint is reinstated on his claim that he was denied overtime for hours that he did not record on his time sheets. The district court rejected plaintiff's claim because he falsified his records to reflect that he did not work overtime and therefore could not prove his damages with precision. The problem with this reasoning is that, according to Keubel, his superiors told him to omit the overtime hours from his time sheets because the company did not want to pay overtime. They told him "you're only supposed to mark forty on your timecard because we can't afford overtime." Acknowledging the realities of life, in addition to the fact that companies cannot delegate their obligation under the FLSA to maintain accurate records of their employees' hours, the Second Circuit says:
At least where the employee’s falsifications were carried out at the instruction of the employer or the employer’s agents, the employer cannot be exonerated by the fact that the employee physically entered the erroneous hours into the timesheets. As the district court emphasized, Kuebel admits that it was he who falsified his timesheets, notwithstanding B&D’s official policy requiring accurate recordkeeping. But his testimony — which must be credited at the summary judgement stage — was that he did so because his managers instructed him not to record more than forty hours per week. He specifically testified that at company meetings and during discussions with one of his supervisors, it was conveyed to him that he was not to record overtime no matter how many hours he actually worked. In other words, Kuebel has testified that it was B&D, through its managers, that caused the inaccuracies in his timesheets.
Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Rule 404(b) errors get defendant a new trial
Prosecutors like propensity evidence. Defense lawyers do not. Propensity evidence is excluded under Federal Rules of Evidence 404(b), but there are enough exceptions to drive a truck through. The real battleground for this is the district court, which has discretion to admit or deny the defendant's prior bad acts. But sometimes, the Court of Appeals overrules the district court. This is one of those cases.
The case is United States v. Curley, decided on April 25. This case provides a nice summary of Rule 404(b) standards and reminds us how tricky these issues can be. The Court of Appeals does not grant criminal defendants a new trial very often, yet the errors here were made by a trial judge who used to be the United States Attorney, so he knew the rules of evidence. But, like I said, those rules are not always easy to apply.
Curley was convicted of stalking and harassing his wife. Curley had a lot of prior bad acts, and so did his brother. The district court allowed the jury to hear this evidence, and the jury threw the book at Curley. Here's the evidence that came before the Second Circuit (Chin, Wesley and Jacobs):
The trial judge allowed the jury to hear all of this evidence. No wonder Curley was convicted. Curley gets a new trial, because the trial court abused its discretion on some of this evidence.
While you cannot admit evidence to show that the defendant is a bad person and is likely to commit crimes again, it may come in for nearly any other purpose so long as it does not unfairly sway the jury. The jury was allowed to hear that Curley was abusive to his wife in 1991, 2001/02 and 2005 because "Curley's abuse of Linda in August 2006 was part of or inextricably intertwined with the charged conduct" as it "was directly relevant to his intent and her fear." The Court adds, "where the charged conduct involves domestic abuse, a spouse's history of domestic violence is relevant to show intent to harass or intimidate his partner ... Although the incidents pre-dated the charged conduct by as much as fifteen years, collectively they demonstrate a patter of activity that continued up to the time of the charged conduct." Not quite propensity evidence, but close, but not too close to render it inadmissible.
Here is where the district court got it wrong: Curley's brother's bad interactions with Linda, i.e., beating Linda before Curley pressured her to lie about it in court, was inadmissible because it "was not sufficiently similar to the charged crimes to allow the jury to reasonable infer Linda's fear." Also, the brother's conduct "did not parallel any of the underlying conduct and this evidence would unduly sway the jury and serve "no real purpose other than to show that Michael -- not Curley -- had a bad character," allowing the jury to speculate that "the 'Curley clan' was coming after Linda."
So what about the stuff in the car during the traffic stop? The government argued that it allowed the jury to believe that Curley was going to pull off a murder-suicide and kill his wife. This is too speculative, the Court of Appeals says, and it does not meet the high admissibility standard for bad acts that post-date the charged crimes. "The record contained insufficient evidence to permit the jury to reasonably infer that Curley expected Linda to be dead when he wrote the will" and "the jury had no reason to determine that Curley planned for Linda to die before him." As the trial court's errors are not harmless, in part because the government highlighted this evidence during summation, Curley gets a new trial.
The case is United States v. Curley, decided on April 25. This case provides a nice summary of Rule 404(b) standards and reminds us how tricky these issues can be. The Court of Appeals does not grant criminal defendants a new trial very often, yet the errors here were made by a trial judge who used to be the United States Attorney, so he knew the rules of evidence. But, like I said, those rules are not always easy to apply.
Curley was convicted of stalking and harassing his wife. Curley had a lot of prior bad acts, and so did his brother. The district court allowed the jury to hear this evidence, and the jury threw the book at Curley. Here's the evidence that came before the Second Circuit (Chin, Wesley and Jacobs):
In January 2008, the police discovered in Curley's car three black powder rifles, ammunition, a bulletproof vest, a ski mask and a last will and testament that would leave all his belongings to his children and asked his sister to take care of his children.
In August 2006, Curley grabbed his wife while she was holding their infant son and would not let go.
In 2005, he pushed his wife into a wall while she was pregnant.
In 2001 or 2002, he shoved his wife and banged her head against the floor.
Also, in 1990, Curley's brother beat up Curley's wife, and Curley pressured her not to call the police.
The trial judge allowed the jury to hear all of this evidence. No wonder Curley was convicted. Curley gets a new trial, because the trial court abused its discretion on some of this evidence.
While you cannot admit evidence to show that the defendant is a bad person and is likely to commit crimes again, it may come in for nearly any other purpose so long as it does not unfairly sway the jury. The jury was allowed to hear that Curley was abusive to his wife in 1991, 2001/02 and 2005 because "Curley's abuse of Linda in August 2006 was part of or inextricably intertwined with the charged conduct" as it "was directly relevant to his intent and her fear." The Court adds, "where the charged conduct involves domestic abuse, a spouse's history of domestic violence is relevant to show intent to harass or intimidate his partner ... Although the incidents pre-dated the charged conduct by as much as fifteen years, collectively they demonstrate a patter of activity that continued up to the time of the charged conduct." Not quite propensity evidence, but close, but not too close to render it inadmissible.
Here is where the district court got it wrong: Curley's brother's bad interactions with Linda, i.e., beating Linda before Curley pressured her to lie about it in court, was inadmissible because it "was not sufficiently similar to the charged crimes to allow the jury to reasonable infer Linda's fear." Also, the brother's conduct "did not parallel any of the underlying conduct and this evidence would unduly sway the jury and serve "no real purpose other than to show that Michael -- not Curley -- had a bad character," allowing the jury to speculate that "the 'Curley clan' was coming after Linda."
So what about the stuff in the car during the traffic stop? The government argued that it allowed the jury to believe that Curley was going to pull off a murder-suicide and kill his wife. This is too speculative, the Court of Appeals says, and it does not meet the high admissibility standard for bad acts that post-date the charged crimes. "The record contained insufficient evidence to permit the jury to reasonably infer that Curley expected Linda to be dead when he wrote the will" and "the jury had no reason to determine that Curley planned for Linda to die before him." As the trial court's errors are not harmless, in part because the government highlighted this evidence during summation, Curley gets a new trial.
Friday, May 6, 2011
Second Circuit affirms large attorneys' fees award
There are two days of reckoning for a defendant that loses a civil rights trial. The first day of reckoning is the amount of the jury verdict, usually read by the jury foreman at the close of trial when the judge asks how much money the plaintiff gets. The other shoe drops a few weeks later, in the form of motion papers filed by the plaintiff's attorney. This is the attorneys' fees motion.
The case is Manzo v. Sovereign Motor Cars, Ltd., a summary order decided on April 15. This is a Title VII case where plaintiff alleged that she was sexually harassed and then retaliated against for complaining about it. The jury awarded her $50,000 in compensatory damages and $200,000 in punitives. The trial court awarded Manzo's attorneys $314,534.00 in attorneys' fees. So Sovereign Motor Cars loses twice.
When someone loses at trial, you often read in the newspaper that they are going to appeal. Appeals are not easy to win, however. It's all about the standard of review. Once the jury weighs in, the Court of Appeals is loathe to second guess its credibility assessments. But challenging the jury's findings is a romp in the park compared with appealing from an award of attorneys' fees. The Court of Appeals reviews fee awards for an "abuse of discretion," a standard that is particularly deferential to the trial court's judgment, owing to the judge's intimate familiarity with the case.
I guess Sovereign Motors couldn't bear the thought of paying more than $300,000 in attorneys' fees on top of the quarter million dollars in damages. The appeal fails. With limited analysis beyond reminding us about the deferential standard of appellate review, the Court of Appeals affirms the attorneys' fees award. For details, you have to read the district court opinion, which provides some insight into how these motions are decided.
As the case was tried in the Eastern District of New York, hourly rates are lower than cases handled in the Southern District. Still, Judge Gleeson awarded lead counsel in this case (with 30 years' experience) $480 per hour. The court notes this is "at the upper end of the range typically awarded in this district," but Judge Gleeson notes that attorney Moskowitz "was brought in to try the case, his trial skills may well be the reason for the favorable jury award, and I conclude that reasonable paying clients would be willing to pay $480 per hour for an attorney of his caliber." Nice words for the prevailing attorney. The other partner who tried the case (with 19 years' experience) was awarded $360 per hour. A lengthy footnote in the district court ruling gives a good summary of recent hourly rates in EDNY cases.
The district court also rejected defendants' challenge to the number of hours expended in litigating the case (987 hours) and allegedly vague billing entries. The trial court also rejected the argument that counsel was not entitled to any fees for litigating unsuccessful claims. These objections are commonplace, and each judge seems to have his or own view on how to resolve them. By way of example, Judge Gleeson upholds the following time entry as sufficiently precise: 12.0 hours for "editing cross examinations of all potential witnesses; editing opening statements; begin work on summation." While one claim did not succeed at trial (involving an overtime violation), it was sufficiently related to the successful harassment claim that counsel could recover for that work. Defendant faces a third penalty: plaintiff's counsel gets fees for work expended on the successful appeal.
The case is Manzo v. Sovereign Motor Cars, Ltd., a summary order decided on April 15. This is a Title VII case where plaintiff alleged that she was sexually harassed and then retaliated against for complaining about it. The jury awarded her $50,000 in compensatory damages and $200,000 in punitives. The trial court awarded Manzo's attorneys $314,534.00 in attorneys' fees. So Sovereign Motor Cars loses twice.
When someone loses at trial, you often read in the newspaper that they are going to appeal. Appeals are not easy to win, however. It's all about the standard of review. Once the jury weighs in, the Court of Appeals is loathe to second guess its credibility assessments. But challenging the jury's findings is a romp in the park compared with appealing from an award of attorneys' fees. The Court of Appeals reviews fee awards for an "abuse of discretion," a standard that is particularly deferential to the trial court's judgment, owing to the judge's intimate familiarity with the case.
I guess Sovereign Motors couldn't bear the thought of paying more than $300,000 in attorneys' fees on top of the quarter million dollars in damages. The appeal fails. With limited analysis beyond reminding us about the deferential standard of appellate review, the Court of Appeals affirms the attorneys' fees award. For details, you have to read the district court opinion, which provides some insight into how these motions are decided.
As the case was tried in the Eastern District of New York, hourly rates are lower than cases handled in the Southern District. Still, Judge Gleeson awarded lead counsel in this case (with 30 years' experience) $480 per hour. The court notes this is "at the upper end of the range typically awarded in this district," but Judge Gleeson notes that attorney Moskowitz "was brought in to try the case, his trial skills may well be the reason for the favorable jury award, and I conclude that reasonable paying clients would be willing to pay $480 per hour for an attorney of his caliber." Nice words for the prevailing attorney. The other partner who tried the case (with 19 years' experience) was awarded $360 per hour. A lengthy footnote in the district court ruling gives a good summary of recent hourly rates in EDNY cases.
The district court also rejected defendants' challenge to the number of hours expended in litigating the case (987 hours) and allegedly vague billing entries. The trial court also rejected the argument that counsel was not entitled to any fees for litigating unsuccessful claims. These objections are commonplace, and each judge seems to have his or own view on how to resolve them. By way of example, Judge Gleeson upholds the following time entry as sufficiently precise: 12.0 hours for "editing cross examinations of all potential witnesses; editing opening statements; begin work on summation." While one claim did not succeed at trial (involving an overtime violation), it was sufficiently related to the successful harassment claim that counsel could recover for that work. Defendant faces a third penalty: plaintiff's counsel gets fees for work expended on the successful appeal.
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Court of Appeals affirms verdict in jail suicide case
This case arises from a suicide at the Putnam County Jail. The inmate's family sued Americor, Inc., which had responsibility for the inmates, on the basis that Americor disregarded an excessive risk to Spencer Sinkov's safety, causing him to hang himself in his jail cell. The Court of Appeals affirms the verdict.
The case is Sinkov v. Americor, Inc., a summary order decided on April 13. Spencer entered the County Jail as a suicide risk. An officer found Spencer hanging from the cell bars by his sweatshirt. A State Corrections Commission report stated that Spencer "had tied the shirt at the top of the front cell bars and sat down." The jury found that he struggled after hanging himself and was alive for a period of time as he tried to alleviate the pressure from the hanging by placing his foot on the bed to raise himself up." This maneuver did not work; Spencer died. Finding that Americor was deliberately indifferent to knowledge that Spencer was a suicide risk, the jury awarded his family $750,000 in damages; as one of the defendants, Americor had to pay $264,000 in damages.
There are few primary issues on appeal. First, Americor says that the jury had no basis to find that it disregarded the suicide risk. But the evidence shows that Spencer answered "yes" to ten questions on the suicide screening form at intake, enough to trigger constant monitoring. The failure to monitor Spencer resulted in his suicide. As Americor knew about New York's minimum standards for detainees who present signs that they are suicide risks, the jury was able to find in favor of Spencer's family. The Second Circuit precedent governing this case is Caiozzo v. Koreman, 581 F.3d 63 (2d Cir. 2009).
Americor also argued that the jury should not have awarded plaintiff $300,000 for conscious pain and suffering. The Court of Appeals (Straub, Sack and Lynch) disagrees. "The jury was entitled to rely on common sense and common experience to conclude that an amateur, improvised hanging is likely to produce a painful death by asphyxiation, and reasonably could have concluded that Sinkov struggled and suffered in the period between when he placed his homemade noose around his neck and when he lost consciousness." As for the $300,000, it does not shock the conscience. Looking at other cases for guidance, the Second Circuit says:
The case is Sinkov v. Americor, Inc., a summary order decided on April 13. Spencer entered the County Jail as a suicide risk. An officer found Spencer hanging from the cell bars by his sweatshirt. A State Corrections Commission report stated that Spencer "had tied the shirt at the top of the front cell bars and sat down." The jury found that he struggled after hanging himself and was alive for a period of time as he tried to alleviate the pressure from the hanging by placing his foot on the bed to raise himself up." This maneuver did not work; Spencer died. Finding that Americor was deliberately indifferent to knowledge that Spencer was a suicide risk, the jury awarded his family $750,000 in damages; as one of the defendants, Americor had to pay $264,000 in damages.
There are few primary issues on appeal. First, Americor says that the jury had no basis to find that it disregarded the suicide risk. But the evidence shows that Spencer answered "yes" to ten questions on the suicide screening form at intake, enough to trigger constant monitoring. The failure to monitor Spencer resulted in his suicide. As Americor knew about New York's minimum standards for detainees who present signs that they are suicide risks, the jury was able to find in favor of Spencer's family. The Second Circuit precedent governing this case is Caiozzo v. Koreman, 581 F.3d 63 (2d Cir. 2009).
Americor also argued that the jury should not have awarded plaintiff $300,000 for conscious pain and suffering. The Court of Appeals (Straub, Sack and Lynch) disagrees. "The jury was entitled to rely on common sense and common experience to conclude that an amateur, improvised hanging is likely to produce a painful death by asphyxiation, and reasonably could have concluded that Sinkov struggled and suffered in the period between when he placed his homemade noose around his neck and when he lost consciousness." As for the $300,000, it does not shock the conscience. Looking at other cases for guidance, the Second Circuit says:
based on the facts of the present case and on a review of pain and suffering awards in other cases, we are satisfied that the jury’s $300,000 award for Sinkov’s conscious pain and suffering was not excessive. See Gonzalez v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth., 555 N.Y.S.2d 107, 108 (1st Dep’t 1990) (“Asphyxiation by gagging, whether it occurred within minutes or within an hour of the initial assault, is a particularly slow and terrifying way to die and, under the circumstances, we do not find the [$350,000] award for conscious pain and suffering ... to be excessive.”); Rodd v. Luxfer USA Ltd., 709 N.Y.S.2d 93, 94 (2d Dep’t 2000) ($300,000 award for pain and suffering where decedent “suffered severe and massive injuries” from any exploding oxygen tank, but the “period of consciousness was limited in duration”); Filipinas v. Action Auto Leasing, 851 N.Y.S.2d 550, 550 (1st Dep’t 2008) ($750,000 award where decedent was struck in the head by a van’s side mirror, and sustained serious head injuries, but “was heavily medicated and/or sedated” within an hour of the accident).
Monday, May 2, 2011
No First Amendment claim for student's offensive blog post
The Court of Appeals has ruled against a Connecticut high school student who sued under the First Amendment after she was denied the opportunity to run for student government after she protested a "battle-of-the-bands" cancellation by calling school administrators "douchebags" in off-campus blog post.
The case is Doninger v. Neihoff, decided on April 25. Doninger was a high-achiever in school, but the JamFest cancellation was enough to send her over the edge. On her blog, she referred to school officials by a most derogatory term and encouraged community members to bombard the district with phone call protests. These calls pulled administrators away from their normal job duties.
Students have the right to speak out so long as the speech does not "materially and substantially disrupt the work and discipline of the school," under a 1969 Supreme Court ruling, Tinker v. Des Moines School District. All public officials, moreover, are immune from suit if they reasonably believe they are not violating the law (even if, in hindsight, they did in fact violate the Constitution). This gives public officials the benefit of the doubt in close cases.
Doninger loses the case on qualified immunity grounds. While she created the blog post off-campus, school officials had an objective basis to find that it actually disrupted the campus. As the Court of Appeals (Livingston, Kearse and Cabranes) puts it:
Moral of the story: if you want to protest the decision of your high school administrators, don't call them "douchebags."
There was another claim here. The school prohibited Doninger from entering a school election assembly with a T-shirt promoting her candidacy, which the school halted as punishment for the offensive blog post. Even if Doninger had the right to wear the T-shirt, school officials reasonably believed that it would disrupt the assembly, which gets them off the hook. This is the qualified immunity defense that I talked about earlier. Showing considerable deference to the judgment of school officials, the Second Circuit reasons:
The case is Doninger v. Neihoff, decided on April 25. Doninger was a high-achiever in school, but the JamFest cancellation was enough to send her over the edge. On her blog, she referred to school officials by a most derogatory term and encouraged community members to bombard the district with phone call protests. These calls pulled administrators away from their normal job duties.
Students have the right to speak out so long as the speech does not "materially and substantially disrupt the work and discipline of the school," under a 1969 Supreme Court ruling, Tinker v. Des Moines School District. All public officials, moreover, are immune from suit if they reasonably believe they are not violating the law (even if, in hindsight, they did in fact violate the Constitution). This gives public officials the benefit of the doubt in close cases.
Doninger loses the case on qualified immunity grounds. While she created the blog post off-campus, school officials had an objective basis to find that it actually disrupted the campus. As the Court of Appeals (Livingston, Kearse and Cabranes) puts it:
The undisputed facts — that Doninger’s blog post directly pertained to an event at [the high school], that it invited other students to read and respond to it by contacting school officials, that students did in fact post comments on the post, and that school administrators eventually became aware of it — demonstrate that it was reasonably foreseeable that Doninger’s post would reach school property and have disruptive consequences there. ... [T]wo additional facts [show] that Doninger’s blog post portended foreseeable disruption to the school’s work and discipline: namely, (1) that the language Doninger employed (asking others to call the “douchebags” in the central office to “piss [them] off more”) was “potentially disruptive of efforts to resolve the ongoing controversy,” and (2) that in the midst of this controversy, Doninger’s blog post conveyed the “‘at best misleading and at wors[t] false’ information that Jamfest had been cancelled in [Doninger’s] effort to solicit more calls and emails to Schwartz.”
Moral of the story: if you want to protest the decision of your high school administrators, don't call them "douchebags."
There was another claim here. The school prohibited Doninger from entering a school election assembly with a T-shirt promoting her candidacy, which the school halted as punishment for the offensive blog post. Even if Doninger had the right to wear the T-shirt, school officials reasonably believed that it would disrupt the assembly, which gets them off the hook. This is the qualified immunity defense that I talked about earlier. Showing considerable deference to the judgment of school officials, the Second Circuit reasons:
Doninger and her supporters were clearly upset about the decision to remove her from the ballot, and were eager to speak out publicly concerning their views. Doninger had appeared on a local news show with her mother to talk about her blog posting and her resulting punishment. She attempted to discuss the news interview in class on the day preceding the election assembly, provoking another student to shout out apparent support in sufficiently disruptive terms that the student was sent to Niehoff’s office. By at least the early morning hours of the day of the election, Niehoff was aware of a plan by students specifically to bring t-shirts supportive of Doninger into an election assembly at which other students, including the two candidates for Senior Class Secretary, were scheduled to speak. Niehoff may not have known with certainty that permitting the t-shirts into the assembly would cause students to disrupt those speeches. But she could not responsibly have ignored the fact that Doninger herself, in her blog post of the previous month, had already demonstrated some willingness to incite confrontation with school officials. And we note further that Niehoff’s concern about the potential disruption of the assembly was partially borne out even in the absence of the t-shirts, when students shouted “Vote for Avery” and had to be warned to be respectful.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)