State and local law makes it illegal to videotape inside police station houses

The Second Circuit last year asked the New York Court of Appeals to weigh in on whether you have a right to record video inside the publicly accessible lobbies of police station houses. The New York Court of Appeals answered that question in the negative, and that ruling now allows the Second Circuit to reject a claim brought by public interest organizations.

The case is Reyes v. City of New York, issued on August 6. Videotaping and recording police activity is one way that civil rights organizations try to keep tabs on law enforcement. But, while everyone has video recording equipment in their pocket these days, that does not mean the law is there for them. It is not.

As I summarized this case back when it first reached the Second Circuit, "The plaintiff in this case sued the City of New York, challenging its policy against video-recording in police facilities, including station house lobbies. He posts his interactions with the police on YouTube, but these videos have gotten him arrested. He claims these arrests violate the First Amendment." Hence plaintiff's challenge to the rules prohibiting such videotaping.

The district court granted plaintiffs a preliminary injunction under state and local law, determining plaintiffs were likely to win their challenge to a NYPD policy prohibiting such video recording. Since the case raised an esoteric issue under state law, the Second Circuit asked the New York Court of Appeals to issue a ruling. The adverse ruling from New York's highest court requires the Second Circuit (Raggi, Kearse and Kahn) to vacate the preliminary injunction.