Friday, November 20, 2026

New York Court of Appeals gives one to the plaintiffs

Every case will undergo a settlement discussion at some point unless the defendant finds a way to successfully file a motion to dismiss. The question is whether the settlement will include or exclude the plaintiff's attorneys' fees. This case look at New York's statute governing settlement offers and answers the question in the affirmative. 

The case is Pramires v. AGDG Car Wash, issued on November 19. Under this ruling, plaintiffs who accept a settlement offer under CPLR 3221 may still recover statutory attorney’s fees, even when the settlement agreement does not expressly preserve their right to seek those fees. 

The plaintiffs accepted the offer and next moved for attorney’s fees under Labor Law §§ 198 and 663, which authorize fee awards to prevailing employees in wage-and-hour litigation. Supreme Court awarded $205,800 in attorney’s fees, exceeding the settlement itself.

Reversing, the Second Department said that because the plaintiffs accepted the settlement without expressly reserving their right to attorney’s fees, those fees were presumed to have been included in the settlement. Under that approach, plaintiffs effectively waived their statutory fee entitlement by accepting the offer without mentioning fees. Not so, says the Court of Appeals. 

CPLR 3221 authorizes defendants to offer judgment for a particular amount together with accrued costs. The statute mentions costs but says nothing about attorney’s fees. That omission, the Court explained, was intentional. An early draft of CPLR 3221 provided for attorney’s fees as part of the financial consequences of rejecting an offer of compromise. But the Legislature removed that language, and the drafters said that attorney’s fees were not included within the statutory definition of costs.

There is a federal counterpart to this statute which is less forgiving for plaintiffs who settle cases under similar circumstances. That's Rule 68. The Court of Appeals declines to follow Marek v. Chesny, 473 U.S. 1 (1985), which holds that attorney’s fees may qualify as costs for Rule 68 purposes when the underlying substantive statute defines them that way. When that happens, the Rule 68 offer may include all attorneys' fees. But unlike Rule 68, CPLR 3221's legislative history proves that attorney’s fees are excluded from costs regardless of the underlying fee-shifting statute.

No comments: